Wits & Weights | Strength & Fat Loss Over 40
You’re over 40, lifting weights, and doing everything right, but your body composition isn’t changing. In every episode I put a popular piece of fitness advice under the microscope, find the hidden reason it doesn’t work, and give you the deceptively simple fix that does. It’s strength training over 40 and fat loss for men and women, built for skeptics of the fitness industry.
If you’re tracking macros and following every rule, you’re probably overcomplicating it. Wits & Weights shows you how to build muscle, lose fat, and achieve real body recomposition by focusing only on what the evidence actually supports. The show centers on women over 40, but plenty of midlife men listen for the same approach.
Evidence-based coach Philip Pape brings an engineer's approach to strength training, nutrition, and metabolism. Instead of another generic program or meal plan, you get specific, science-based strategies for body recomposition, whether you're focused on building muscle, losing fat, or both. The focus is on strength training over 40, body recomposition for women over 40, perimenopause and menopause fitness, metabolism recovery, hormone health, and longevity.
You've seen the conflicting advice, even on other nutrition podcasts. One expert says cut carbs, the next says eat more. One says train six days a week, another says three is plenty. Building the body you want doesn't have to be this confusing or time-consuming.
By using your wits (systems plus identity-based behavior change) and lifting weights, you can build muscle, improve your physique, and maintain your results for life without rebound weight gain. You'll also learn about metabolism recovery, and why years of dieting can lead to metabolic adaptation that makes fat loss harder than it needs to be.
You'll learn smart, efficient strategies for movement, metabolism, muscle, and mindset: why fat loss matters more than weight loss, why all the macros (protein, fats, and yes even carbs) are critical to body composition, how just 3 hours a week of proper hypertrophy training can outperform twice that time, why building muscle is the single most powerful thing you can do for metabolic health and longevity, why perimenopause and menopause don't have to derail your progress, and how shifting the way you think about fitness drives more growth than any program alone.
Looking for fat loss podcasts, nutrition podcasts, or strength training podcasts for women and men over 40? Wits & Weights brings the science-based answers without the conflicting noise. If you're ready to learn what actually works, hit "follow."
Popular Guests: Greg Nuckols (Stronger by Science), Alan Aragon (nutrition researcher), Eric Helms (3D Muscle Journey), Dr. Spencer Nadolsky (Docs Who Lift), Bill Campbell (exercise science researcher), Jordan Feigenbaum (Barbell Medicine), Holly Baxter (evidence-based physique coach), Laurin Conlin (physique coach), Lauren Colenso-Semple (nutrition researcher), Karen Martel (hormone optimization expert), Steph Gaudreau (women's strength and nutrition), Bryan Boorstein (hypertrophy coach)
Popular Topics: strength training for women over 40, strength training over 40, women's strength training, body recomposition for women over 40, body recomposition after 40, body recomposition, muscle building after 40, muscle building, hypertrophy training, fat loss for women over 40, perimenopause fitness, menopause fitness, menopause metabolism, metabolism recovery, metabolic adaptation, protein for women over 40, nutrition for lifters over 40, hormone health, longevity and healthy aging, lifting weights for fat loss, macros and nutrition tracking
Wits & Weights | Strength & Fat Loss Over 40
PHILIP'S PICK: Why Stable Weight Doesn't Always Mean You're Eating Enough (From The Mind Muscle Connection)
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Is your body weight stable, but you're still not eating enough to properly fuel your training, recovery, and overall health?
Introducing Why Stable Weight Doesn't Always Mean You're Eating Enough from Jeff Hoehn of the Mind Muscle Connection Podcast.
Just because your weight isn't changing doesn't necessarily mean you're adequately fueled.
In this episode, Jeff breaks down why maintaining a stable body weight doesn't always mean you're meeting your body's energy needs, especially if you're training hard, staying lean, or spending long periods dieting.
You'll learn:
- Why stable body weight doesn't automatically mean adequate energy availability
- Who is most at risk of underfueling, even when their weight isn't changing
- How high training output, staying too lean, and chronic dieting can contribute to low energy availability
- The potential signs of underfueling, including changes in performance, recovery, hormones, and menstrual health
- Why spending too long trying to recomp can sometimes work against your goals
- Practical strategies to improve fueling, support muscle growth, and prioritize long-term health
If you're training consistently but struggling with progress, recovery, or how you feel day to day, this episode is for you.
Follow the show: Mind Muscle Connection Podcast
Work with Jeff: jhhealth.net/workwithme
DISCLAIMER: We're sharing this episode as part of a feed swap and did not produce it. The views expressed are solely those of the creator, and any products, programs, or offers mentioned are their own.
Get 30% off Fitness Lab (through Dec 3)
More from Wits & Weights:
📱 Get 20% off Fitness Lab (exclusive to podcast listeners), the AI coaching app for strength training and nutrition over 40
🎁 Get my free guides
💪 Join Eat More Lift Heavy, the 26-week coached program to build muscle and lose fat after 40
📊 Track your nutrition with MacroFactor and use code WITSANDWEIGHTS for a 2-week free trial
👥 Join the free Facebook community
Educational content only, not medical advice.
Hey, it's Philip, and today I'm sharing an episode from the Mind Muscle Connection, hosted by my friend Jeff Hoehn. He is a strength coach who you have definitely heard on this show before. We've collaborated on both of our shows. If your weight is holding steady, that doesn't mean that you're eating enough. Jeff is going to explain why, who's most at risk of underfueling, and what to do about it. One of my favorite topics. Any offers you hear are Jeff's, not mine. And of course, if you enjoy his show, follow the Mind Muscle Connection wherever you listen or use the link in the show notes. Here's Jeff with his episode. why stable weight doesn't always mean you're eating enough. Enjoy.
Jeff HoehnHey guys, welcome back to another episode of the Mind Muscle Connection podcast. Today is a sole episode, and I want to talk about a topic around just because your weight is stable doesn't automatically equal you being adequately fueled. Like you still may be under-eating. We'll go over some signs that this is happening, symptoms, what would be the downstream impacts of this, who's who this is most commonly, who's most commonly going to run into this, and what are some things that we can do within that. And before we dive into that, just want to go over a few ways you can help support the podcast. So first, if you are interested in taking your body composition to the next level, maybe you need to get back on track. Maybe you just want to learn more things around building muscle, losing body fat, how to work on your how to do things for your specific body, then my coaching is for you. I'm always looking to add more motivated clients that want to learn these things, want to get a deeper insight into their own training, nutrition, and how their bodies work. Then again, this is for you there. So if you're interested in learning more about this, you can either reach out to me on Instagram, Jeff H-O-E-H N underscore, or uh you can fill out the link in the show notes and we can set up some time to chat about it in more detail. So with that out of the way, let's dive into today's topic. So, like I said, I want to talk about a lot of times people will think, hey, if their weight's stable, that they're at maintenance and they're adequately fueling their body, right? Now I'm saying that if your weight is not changing, it's staying around the same over time, you are probably fairly close to your maintenance calories at that point in time. However, it is somewhat of a moving target. And so we still may be under-eating in this situation. And so this is where a lot of people end up getting themselves stuck long term, right? Their weight's not moving and they think that, hey, they're at maintenance and they can't figure out why they gain weight when they go a little bit higher than this. And so we're gonna dive into that specifically here today. So again, many people assume, hey, my weight hasn't changed. Either in and again, it's like, hey, I'm eating at maintenance, and so I must be eating enough. And again, not necessarily, right? Because weight stability tells you that your weight is stable, but it doesn't automatically tell you that your body is adequately fueled. And this may be again why a lot of people feel stuck and end up getting to the point of what I like to call artificially low maintenance calories, right? And so, again, like I said, I want to go over who is most likely, who is at a higher risk of this happening to? Some signs that you may not be eating enough despite your weight being stable. Some things that we can look at, right? Because I think it's important because there's gonna probably be some people that listen to this that are having trouble maybe dropping body fat, and then they're going to think that, oh, it's because I'm not eating enough. And that's obviously not the case. There'll be things that we need to look at here within that. And then I'm gonna talk about hey, what do I typically do with clients in this situation there? Again, let's dive into this. So, who's gonna be at a high risk of this? One, it's gonna be somebody that has a high training output. Okay. And so having a high training output doesn't automatically mean you aren't eating enough. It's just gonna put you at a higher risk of underfueling, right? Because again, think about this the more you train, the more energy your body is going to need for that, right? Not necessarily to just fuel the workout, but to also recover and then also take care of other basic bodily functions as well, too, right? And on top of that, what will generally happen is a body will compensate for higher exercise energy expenditure by reducing energy expenditure elsewhere, right? So, like, for example, reductions in need. So you may just burn less calories throughout the day elsewhere. And this is especially true, I think the higher your output is and the lower that caloric intake is, right? So it's like you have this high output, but your body sort of adjusts by expending energy elsewhere. And then again, other basic bodily functions may not be able to get taken care of, right? This is one way to be in a state of low energy availability is through high energy expenditure and not bringing up your calories high enough. And then we'll talk about you're probably gonna fall into some other things here where you're probably scared about seeing your scale weight comp at all. Maybe you do have to feel like you need to be at a low body weight, or it's just simply is you have such a high training output that it's hard for you to get in enough calories because again, maybe you run into GI issues, or maybe you are trying to eat too high quality, like too much food volume, right? You're almost this is more unintentional than anything, but you're probably also falling into maybe some of these other categories. But again, just generally speaking, if we have a high training output and just understand that we're already at a little bit of a higher risk of having our weight be stable, but we may not be adequately fueling our body enough here, right? And then again, there's some delayation down the line. And so we'll talk about, hey, what are some actual things that may happen in this state? But again, just generally speaking, you have a high training output. Now, this isn't somebody that's gonna that goes and does four days of lifting and gets 10,000 steps, you're probably not gonna be at that at a risk of this, right? This is gonna be somebody that trains seven days a week, high a lot of endurance type training, you're going on multiple runs per week, you're also doing some weight training, maybe you do some long distance, yeah, any sort of long distance sport. You play a sport, right? But again, if you're somebody who is getting 8,000 steps a day and you lift three days a week, you're not gonna be someone that we need to worry about this with, right? This would be someone that also moves 25,000 steps a day plus goes on runs, right? Like they're just doing again, athletes would definitely fall into this. And then just people that are athletes as well, too, right? But again, I think it's that clear distinction where a lot of people think, oh, hey, I'm training four days, weight training four days a week and getting 10,000 steps. No, you're not at risk of of this, right? Like you kind of are excluded from this. Now, again, that person can still under-eat, no, definitely, and they can still have some of these symptoms, but they just wouldn't fall into this high training output, right? Like we're talking, hey, you're doing a lot here, right? So again, if you have this high training output, you need to just put in your head, like, okay, hey, I could be at a risk, even though my weight is stable, right? And again, we'll, as I said earlier, we will talk about some things that could show up here in these situations. Maybe you're someone who's trying to stay very lean year round, or you're trying to maintain your absolute lowest body weight. So this would show up with somebody who maybe feels like they need to stay super lean. They want to have, they want to be shredded year round, they want to, maybe they're doing it for social media. Maybe there's some sort of external pressure to stay super lean, right? Whether that be for a sport, or again, maybe your job requires it, right? You could definitely say that some trainers, people that work in the fitness industry, fall into this, right? Like they feel like they need to maintain a super lean physique all the time. And again, they don't really realize that to maintain that, they kind of have to be in this underfield state at all times, right? Remember though, we're gonna we're I'm gonna come back to this and discuss some symptoms that somebody may have within this, right? Again, we're not diving deep into how this may show up and what this may look like for somebody, right? Because again, when we try to stay too lean, and again, this is being the too lean being too lean side of things is gonna probably show up between sub 10 to 12 percent for men, sub 18 to 25 percent for women. Women are gonna probably have a little bit of a higher threshold of this where they're gonna start to notice changes or issues, and then there's probably gonna be a lot more variation, right? Whereas you may have one uh, you know, uh one woman that may be able to be at 25% and she's running into issues, whereas and she starts to see some of these things that we'll talk about in a little bit, and then another person's totally fine, right? That that so there's a lot more individual variation within this, right? And then it can start to creep up a little bit higher. Whereas like for a lot of men, if you're in that 10 to 12% range, you're probably fine. It's not really a big deal. Again, you may see some men that do notice a difference, but then once you get under 10%, that's where you really start to see people, like most people are gonna start to run into issues, right? And again, that range for women's probably the range is larger, it's higher because women need more essential body fat and there's more individual variation in there. But again, once you go under 18%, like you're probably gonna find more and more people are gonna run into some issues. Now, remember with the body fat percentage, don't get caught up in the exact numbers here. It just generally speaking, the leaner you are, the more this could potentially show up. So that's one side of it, is just trying to maintain too low of body fat levels. Now, in saying that, real quick before I move on, the being too lean thing, I do think your inputs are super important here, right? What I mean by that if is if someone's not managing their training load, they're not sleeping very well, they don't have good micronutrient density, their macros are all out of whack, you're not gonna be able to dip into those lower body fat percentages and stay there. You're gonna start to run into issues, regardless of genetics where your body feels comfortable at, that's gonna make things more challenging. Whereas the more those things are dialed in, you probably can hang out a little bit lower on this lower end there. However, the other side of things would be somebody that's also trying to just maintain their absolute lowest body weight. And this could show up in someone that's not necessarily overly lean, it could be somebody that's very lean, but this can also show up with somebody that's maybe lost a significant amount of weight and you're trying to maintain that your lowest body weight indefinitely. So again, you may not necessarily be lean from like a body fat percentage perspective. You may just be trying to keep a very low body weight and you may have slightly higher body fat percentage, but maybe you just don't have a lot of muscle. And that's just because, again, you want to be super low in body weight, you feel like you need to, you just need to maintain this really low body weight for whatever reason, or you're somebody who has lost a significant amount of weight, you've hit that kind of new low, and now you won't ever let your body weight come up, even just a tiny bit, right? If you're like, I have to keep going down and I have to keep this as low as possible. I lost all this weight, I'm not gaining any of it back. There's probably a psychological piece to this, probably a big psychological piece to this, but just understand that if we're trying to maintain a low caloric intake to maintain a body weight like that, that can become problematic, right? It's like you may be maintaining your weight, but your body is just adapted to what is going on, right? I think in both of these situations, regardless if you're very lean or you've lost a lot of weight, it ends up being that the amount that you the what you need to eat to maintain that is in a somewhat adaptive state. Your metabolism is in an adaptive state. Now I'm saying that it's not always going to stay that way, but it's in that adaptive state. And the amount of calories that you're at in the state to keep that is just not gonna be enough, right? And so that's ultimately what the crux of the issue here is with both of these on there. So again, if you're someone that does obviously this is even more of a case if you also have a high training output, right? If you're an athlete. So again, just keep in mind if you're someone that has you're trying to maintain a very lean year-round look, you're not automatically going to be someone that is not adequately, you may, you aren't necessarily someone that automatically is gonna be at this state. It could be, but not automatically. There's a higher chance. Same thing with the high training load. And then again, if you're trying to maintain like a very low body weight for whatever reason, whether that's you've lost a lot of weight, you're trying to maintain that low one, or again, you're just trying to keep a low body weight for whatever reason, and maybe you don't have a lot of muscle, again, you could be in these states, you're at a higher risk here, right? Again, it's not a for sure thing. It's just, hey, you are at a a higher risk here. The next one that where this could potentially be an issue is you're afraid of seeing the scale increase. Now, this is probably going to go hand in hand with the last one I just said, but if you are someone that every time you see the scale weight go up, say from one day to the next, and then you immediately restrict your caloric intake and/or just move a ton, you also may be at risk here of having your weight be stable, but you're not necessarily fueling enough overall, right? So again, this is probably someone that may fall into that last kind of category of you're trying to maintain your lowest weight. But again, this also happens a lot with people where they see the scale come up and they're like, oh crap, I gotta like restrict. I can't eat as much. I have to really dial back what I'm doing. And it kind of leads to that sort of yo-yo type situation there, right? So again, this can also lead to your weight being stable, but not necessarily fueling enough there. And then you maybe have spent, so the next person that's at a higher risk of this is someone that's trying to spend too long trying to recomp, right? So you're trying to kind of get the best of both worlds here of losing some body fat and building muscle at the same time. Even though it's a small calorie deficit, because again, if we're truly recomping, eventually that calorie deficit's gonna have to, it can't be super, it can't be a large deficit, it needs to be a smaller deficit. And so it's like you're not really gonna notice a lot of of these downsides of being in a deficit, like it's gonna be a slower burn and you're also, hey, losing some body fat building muscle. That's the quote unquote holy grail what people are looking for. And so you can kind of get almost married to that and think that you can do this forever. But eventually what happens is you keep losing some body fat, your body's slowly adapting. And we'll talk about what those things are here in a little bit. And then next thing you know, it's like you're at what I call artificially low maintenance calories, right? It's like your body is you're slowly adapting, so that's trending down over time. And then you just kind of have to keep lowering your calories slightly to stay in that state. And eventually you get to the point to where it's not gonna be a good environment to build more muscle, and then all the downstream impacts of lowering body fat, et cetera, will still show up, but it's like more of a less, you're not gonna notice it as much. And I think that's where it can be tricky here, right? And eventually you get to the point to where your body weight's stable, but you're still like now in this lower energy state, you're at again artificially low maintenance calories, and again, where things can start to, you can start to see some impacts there. But like I said, it is a slower burn and it's this is a little bit tougher to catch because it's hey, you're not really feeling it in the short term, but over the long term it starts to add up. So again, if you're trying to recomp for too long, you can also be at a higher risk here of this. Again, if you chronically diet or repeatedly cycle between fat loss phases, right? If you're just you diet for a little bit, again, maybe within that you're kind of yo-yoing, you're having some days where you're on, you're not. But at the end of the day, you're always just trying to lose a little bit more weight. You are at a risk of your weight being stable but underfueling, right? Again, it is mostly going to come down to your metabolism is likely adapted in some form or fashion, just because again, you're not really like, you're not really going all in on one or the other, right? You're kind of dipping into fat loss. You do it for a little bit, and then maybe you don't stay on track. Now we're at this point where you probably, from a body comp perspective, have a little bit higher body fat levels, lower muscle, right? And you're having these periods where you under eat and then periods where you overeat, right? And so it's like you are somewhat suppressing your metabolism. And again, you may that number may be low, which is going to lead to all these other issues that I'll discuss here in a little bit, right? So again, if you chronically diet or repeatedly cycle between fat loss phases, never give yourself time to eat enough, but actually stay consistent with that, right? Not like dipping in and out of it, but actually give yourself time to do that. Again, you may be at a higher risk here of this. Or if you're someone who just eats like a low carbohydrate diet, 247, 365. Again, this is especially true if you're maintaining a high training load. Again, you don't need to eat huge amounts of carbohydrates, especially if you don't train much, but chronically eating very low carb while training hard may increase your risk of underfueling. And so again, that's if somebody's like always low carb, like all the time. They've just always been under 100, 150. If they they never want to add in carbohydrates overall, again, you're gonna be someone that your weight could be stable, but you're still technically underfueling and not eating enough there, especially if you have high training output. So a couple of things I want to go over before we get into some signs, again, from like a subjective and also objective standpoint, is I think this is more, these are more likely to happen in people that are. I hate to use just BMI as something, but I do think it can give us an idea here of what's going on, right? BMI doesn't tell us everything, but generally speaking, once you kind of get into those the high end of the overweight category, obese categories, it's less likely that you're under-eating, if that makes sense. There's other things that could be going on. But again, this is more likely to happen in people that I would say are lower chance than someone who's in the overweight category. Now, somebody could definitely have a lot of muscle and end up being there, but less likely to happen, could still happen at the lower end of the overweight range. But once we kind of get into the kind of normal and slightly lower, this is these are where people are going to start to fall into this category, right? Because what I don't want is someone to be think that, hey, I'm not eating enough and that's why I'm not losing body fat, right? That's not necessarily what is going on here. So again, it could be the case, like the it, I guess basically it's not necessarily just a calorie thing, is what I'm getting at for these people that are maybe in the the higher overweight, higher obese, in the obese or higher range, right? It's probably not necessarily you need to eat more calories. It could just be a little bit more, hey, you need to be more regular with your nutrition. Maybe it's filling in some gaps in terms of micro, right? Maybe it's just taking some time away from trying to lose weight all the time, right? We'll go over some things that we can do, but I just wanted to make that distinction clear that again, this is probably more likely to happen in people that are maybe on the very low end of overweight and then under in terms of BMI. Even though BMI is not perfect, it does still trend well from that perspective. Now, I guess one caveat to that where higher BMI could fall into this would be somebody that is kind of yo-yo dieting, right? You go through phases where you do lose some weight and then you gain weight back, right? So I guess that's the big distinction. If you've just always seen your weight kind of climb up, you've never really dropped some weight, again, you're less likely to be in this. Whereas someone that would potentially fall into this would be somebody that has kind of chronically dieted or repeatedly cycled there. So again, out of all those things, the people that are more like most likely to potentially be at a risk here are going to be people that are on the leaner side, have had some sort of weight loss at some point in time recently. You do a lot of training, or again, you again, you did already lose some some body weight in, say, a fat loss phase, right? These would be the people that would be at the highest risk. Or again, you've just never, you've always tried to maintain a super low body weight, right? So again, hope that kind of clears up who this would fall into and who maybe it's like, okay, if you're not losing weight, it's not that you're it's there's other things going on there. All right. So, anyways, let's go into the potential signs. Again, you're you fall into that list. All right, now we need to, again, that doesn't ensure that you're at this point. It's just, all right, that's the risk, the the people that are higher risk. All right. So the the signs are one, you have poor or declining training performance. So your training performance has just been down for a while. It's like you aren't able to do what you used to do, or it's just continuously getting worse, right? And this could be in the short term, this could be in the long term, right? One poor training session doesn't mean you're underfueling. It could mean in the short term that you did underfuel for that day, but in general, it's not that you're necessarily underfueling, right? So again, if that if we're seeing our training decline, or again, it's just it's been low for a while, definitely a sign that even though you're well fueled that or that your weight's stable, that you still may be underfueling, right? So again, you're kind of have these higher RPE workloads that previously felt easier, right? So that's the first thing. Now, like I said, that's not the only thing. There's a lot of things that go into that, like sleep could be something that goes into this, right? Now sleep is obviously impacted by all this too. So it goes into that. But just again, one poor training session, or again, maybe you are just doing too much training, right? There's more that goes into it. But again, this is just one sign or symptom here that you're at this stage. Slow recovery or more frequent injury. So if you are finding that you're getting just beat up a little bit more from training, you're slower to recover, you just have slower recovery in general, right? Again, a sign that you, even though your body weight's stable, you still potentially could be underfueling here, right? Again, this could be a training load sleep thing. But again, if we're also weight stable, eating what we think is a little bit of a lower maintenance calories than than what we would think. Again, you're definitely at a higher risk here. You just have lower energy throughout the day, right? So again, you're just whether it be in the morning, throughout the day, you just feel you don't feel like super energized anymore. Again, all three of these could certainly be a sleep thing as well. So like we have to, like, this is where it can get fairly challenging to know if it is an eating thing or if it's a sleep thing. Now, it is important to evaluate things like your iron panel panel, as this as iron deficiency can produce similar symptoms. You do need to look at that as well, too, because that is something that that could, you know, yes, underfueling could definitely lead to that. High training output could lead to that, but is it, hey, you just need a little bit more iron, right? And this was especially going to be in somebody who has a high training output, women in particular, pre-menopause, pause them there. Next, dysregulated hunger and craving. So again, some people may have very little hunger. Sometimes you see this where it's like they don't feel hungry, so then it's like, hey, weight's stable, so I'm fine, right? Or some may have excessive hunger, and then others may swing back and forth between the two, right? And that's where the more dysregulated kind of hunger and cravings come in. So again, if you feel like that's out of whack and weight stable, definitely a sign. Like again, it could be a sleep thing, it could be a meal timing thing. So it's hard to isolate just this. But again, another thing is you can start to see here, the more of these we start to stack up, it's like, hey, weight's stable, but this doesn't make sense. You're getting sick more often, right? So again, looking at things like your white blood cell counts may also will be helpful and you can look at that on your blood work, right? So if they're lower, again, another kind of thing in the bucket that's hey, even though our weight's stable, we could be underfeeling here. And so, again, if we're just getting sick more often there. Now, same thing there. This could we could bring this back to sleep. Is it a sleep thing? Is it just a high training load relative to our recovery? Is it high training load relative to our nutrition, right? So yeah, it's hard to find to pinpoint what it is, but you again, we're starting to see how many of these things can start to add up. Reduce spontaneous movement. So you're neat. Again, difficult to measure directly, but you may notice yourself taking fewer steps, leaning on things more often, or simply feeling more lethargic throughout the day. So it goes hand in hand with the lower energy throughout the day. But again, if we're finding that we're just more lethargic overall, moving less, again, that is a sign and symptom that you could be underfeeling despite your weight being at maintenance. Again, if you're having a harder time building muscle. So if you're someone that feels like you're a hard gainer, this could be something that you're dealing with, right? So your body may not have enough resources available to maximize muscle growth, especially if training quality is also declining. Because with is it because you don't have enough fuel available to push training, or again, are we just not in the right environment to build muscle? So again, if you're having a harder time building muscle and energy is low, weight stable, like definitely a sign that you could be underfueling there. Because again, the body's not going to prioritize muscle growth in this state. Fat loss becomes more difficult to sustain, right? Again, if your metabolism has adapted, which it's only currently adapted, your intake, you know, it's adapted by conserving energy, right? It's not going to be as spinful with the energy. It's going to just conserve it a bit more. So the only way to continue losing fat becomes eating even less, which unfortunately causes many of these issues to become even worse, right? So it's like, all right, if you're in the state, well, I'll just drop calories. Well, again, this is where people get themselves stuck, is they've been living at this lower, they haven't been feeling enough, even though their weight's been stable. And then now they try and go back and lose some more body fat, and it's just their body's just gonna fight that a little bit more. You have to go even lower. And then unfortunately, that's gonna make all these things that I'm going over even worse over time. So again, you could see where someone in the state is in decent shape, but they're stuck and they don't really know where to go, right? Because it's like they're having a harder time building muscle, and they also fat loss is a lot tougher in this situation. And again, you're gonna have a reduced resting metabolic rate. So again, this would be metabolic adaptation, right? So again, this would be more of an objective thing that you could look at if you look at your BMR. Well, there's obviously more that goes into your metabolic rate. If you could somehow get your total daily energy expenditure and you've seen that trend down again, that's a sign that you're in this state, even though you're eating at maintenance, right? Because a lot of people think, hey, if I just eat at maintenance, like that's that's perfect. Like I'm gonna, my metabolism's gonna ramp up and I'm gonna be it's gonna be perfect. But again, if we're not fueling enough because we're scared to see calories come up or see scale weight come up a little bit, again, you can get yourself stuck in this state where you are at a slightly reduced metabolic rate, and there's still some metabolic adaptation going on. Now, again, that Will go away over time, but for scared to increase calories and get past that point, this is where you can get trapped over time. You may see on blood work lower T3, right? So this is the active thyroid hormone. So again, this can impact energy expenditure, energy levels, recovery, and to an extent, your ability to build muscle and to lose body fat. We don't necessarily want to be hyper-thyroid, right? Like you don't want to have super high levels of thyroid because that's obviously not going to be helpful from a muscle building standpoint, but hypo will impact your ability to build muscle. And again, this will be low in these states. So again, your weight may be stable, and then you look and T3 is low. Like that's definitely a sign that we're eating, we're eating enough to stabilize our weight, but that doesn't necessarily mean that we're feeling enough. Now, again, this can show up more in someone who has a higher training output, right? Again, this is where you now start to see hormonal levels get impacted, right? Testosterone, estrogen, progesterone. Again, blood work can help identify these. So seeing where those levels are at, right? So in men, you may see that testosterone's a bit lower in the state. Again, and with women, you may see low estrogen, maybe low progesterone, that that balance is gonna be off. But many of the symptoms discussed in this post may also provide clues. So we don't necessarily need to go and get blood work done for that. I don't think it's a bad idea to do it, but just understand that if you're experiencing a lot of these other things that we're talking about here, that can be what's going on, right? But generally speaking, if you're in this state, you probably are gonna see these things. Now, estrogen is gonna have for women, it's gonna be helpful from like a bone health perspective, probably gonna impact your energy expenditure slightly. It's gonna put your body in a better position to build muscle. So if that's low because we're in this state where we're just trying to maybe maintain too high of an output on too low calories or we're trying to maintain too low of a body weight, this is where you can start to run into these issues here. And then you'll start to see if you have some menstrual cycle disturbances. So again, this is gonna be examples of missed periods, irregular cycles, longer or shorter cycles, or lack of ovulation. These are all signs that, you know, even though our weight's stable, we're not necessarily fueling enough there. So you'd want to look at that as well too. And then reduced bone health over time. So again, this can be assessed with DEXA or this may present as stress fractures or recurrent bone injury. So again, you see these stress fractures a lot more in say women that are doing high amounts of endurance, right? And this comes back to what I said earlier. You could have this high training output, and that's gonna be a risk factor for you running into these issues, even though you may be eating what you deem is a lot of calories, right? But you were like last time I did, I went from 2,020, 200, I gained two pounds, and so I went back to 2,000, right? And then, or you were eating 2,000 consistently, and one day your scale weight went up, and then you're like, oh crap, I gotta decrease my calories, right? This is where you can get yourself stuck in the cycles. Again, these are things that we want to look at. With the thyroid, we're also looking at, hey, are you cold regularly? What is that like? If that that's a sign that you could be low thyroid, it could also be low iron, right? Again, women and pre-menopausal women and people that have high endurance may be at a higher risk of this of iron there, right? Now that we have these symptoms, again, like I was saying, you can really start to see where this can creep up, right? Uh again, you may not necessarily, again, I think this would show up in someone that maybe you think your calories are fairly high and your weight's maintaining and you feel good, but you may still be consuming calories, right? You may need a little bit more. You may find that your maintenance calories are a bit higher, right? Or if you're someone again that is anytime you see your scare weight go up, you drop calories. Again, you can get yourself in the state despite your weight being stable, right? And again, if we're living too lean, where it's like, hey, I don't want to gain any body fat, I need to be super shredded all the time, that's fine. You but that's where again you'll run into some issues here of your the calorie amount for you may not be enough. And you're trying to maintain this level of leanness that your body doesn't feel great at. Now, again, like I was saying, your inputs do matter. So maybe there's some things that we could do from an input perspective, but these would be the things I'd be looking at. And then again, afraid of seeing the scale increase. Now, coming back to that one, just because your scale weight goes up two pounds doesn't mean you're in a surplus, right? That can fluctuate from day to day. Also, if you're trying to increase your calories from the end of your fat loss phase, there's gonna be that period where your scale weight's gonna come up a little bit and you have to be okay with that. Otherwise, you're gonna get yourself stuck in this state despite your weight being stable. And you're gonna have what you feel like is a low maintenance calories, right? But again, let's come back to the recomp one. If you've been trying to spend too long trying to recomp where you're trying to do both at the same time, again, you slowly see your scale weight trend down. Maybe it stays slightly the same, you are losing some body fat, but you're also building muscle. Again, eventually over time, that's gonna lead to all these issues when you're gonna have a lower maintenance calorie range than what you could, which again, when we're eating lower calories, now we're not fueling our body enough. And again, your body's going to have these adaptations in place that will downregulate energy and downregulate other processes. Reproduction is one of them, right? Just general energy levels. Again, like I was saying, having trouble building muscle. Again, these are not things that we need to have, right? Our body's gonna be like, hey, we don't need to prioritize these. So we're gonna downregulate those systems there. And so that's what you'll ultimately see happen here in these states, despite your weight being stable. Now, if your weight's stable and you're not experiencing these things, then you're probably fine. But again, it just is if you feel like your maintenance calories are lower than what they should be, it could be a tracking thing or it could be one of these things. You might need to get you need to be okay with increasing your calories a little bit, right? But it could also just be a an input thing, right? We talked about that being something that that again, if you're also trying to go low carb, maybe you need to increase carbs a little bit, right? Now, but that also comes back to maybe skill weight needs to come up there. So I think there's different ways that we can get here. And it's just identifying where do you fall, and then is it actually something that you need to change, right? And then I guess the other thing would be you can also get blood work to see this, right? If you're trying to maintain a certain level of leanness in your thyroid, it may just be that you're trying to live too lean. You may or too low a body weight, you may need to increase calories for a little bit, and then that will come back on track. Same thing with testosterone. If you're a male and your testosterone's on the lower end and you feel like you're like, hey, I thought I need to eat enough, you could just be trying to be too lean or you're trying to maintain too low of a body weight, right? You may need to see that come up. I think the body weight thing's gonna happen more in women than in men, but it that certainly happens with men as well, too, where I've seen men get themselves stuck with low thyroid, low testosterone because they're scared to see their scale weight come up because they think they're gonna gain a bunch of body weight there. And then again, you need to look at menstrual cycle disturbances. Those are gonna be super helpful. Bone health, right? Super helpful, especially for women there. So again, it could, like I said, it could be an input thing where we need, it's not necessarily you need to increase calories. It could be an input thing, meal timing, training load, et cetera, but it could also be a calorie thing. So, in saying that, let's talk about what I typically do with clients in these situations, because I think that's gonna put a nice bow on all this. One, potentially increase calorie intake appropriately if we deem that you need that, right? You don't need to necessarily, you don't need to dramatically increase calories, but you do need to increase them, right? I typically start with about a hundred to two hundred calorie increase, usually by increasing carbohydrates. And if you're really worried about it, put more of your carbohydrates around your workouts. I think that could, that can go a long way, right? Like I said, if you're someone that is yo-yo dieting up and down, you're a little bit of a higher body fat percentage. I don't think you necessarily need to increase your calories. I think it's staying consistent, being more consistent with that caloric range and then probably increasing your input or yeah, improving your input. So whereas if you're somebody that's on the leaner side of things and you're scared to see your scale weight come up at all, it may be, hey, you need to increase your calories and then actually stick with that versus reverting back to lower calories, right? So that's one thing that we could do there. Next, eat enough carbohydrates to support your training. I think these do go hand in hand, but carbs are gonna help support recovery and training performance. And overall calorie intake does matter, but I do think having enough carbohydrates for your training level is also important. So if you're also been slashing carbs for a long period of time, you may need to increase your carbohydrates for a short period of time, or at least, yeah, for not necessarily a short period of time, but enough time there. We also need to make sure we periodize fat loss phases instead of dieting year round. So eventually we need to make sure that we we're not always trying to lose more weight. I want to get clients to four or three to one ratio of eating enough versus dieting throughout the year. So we also need to take longer breaks from fat loss dieting there. I think it's important to also reduce unnecessary training volume if recovery is poor. In some cases, spending time with lower training volume while increasing calorie intake is exactly what your body needs. Again, if you're someone that lifts three days a week and eight thousand steps a day, I don't think you need to lower your training volume for a little bit. But if you're someone that trains seven days a week, you do four or five runs, three or four lifting days, but you also try to get 20,000 steps, it's like, okay, we probably need to manage that training volume for a short period of time here. But we obviously need to prioritize sleep, circadian rhythm, and stress load management. And a lot of these things can creep up and then say, hey, this person's only sleeping six hours, they're on their phone till 2 a.m. and they're super stressed. It's like, all right, we need to work on those things before just saying we need to increase calories. So I'd at least be doing that in combination. Now, in saying that, if I would increase calories, depends on all those things I talked about before. But we have to also focus on our sleep, circadian rhythm, and stress load management. Another underrated one is improving the micronutrient quality of your diet. So I like to use chronometer with clients to identify nutrients they may be low in. The most common ones I see are iron, zinc, magnesium, copper, and omega-3s, although there are certainly others as well, but these are just the most common I see, right? So again, iron, especially in vegan, vegans, athletes, right? Zinc's gonna be a big one. Copper's a huge one that does have a role in, say, iron metabolism as well, too. Copper's a big one. Magnesium, and then, like I said, omega-3s are gonna be super helpful here in this process. So again, we also need to improve the micronutrient quality of our diet. If we, it could be a calorie thing, but it could also be that we need to improve the nutrition, right? And this also comes back to that person that I was saying. Maybe you're a little bit higher on the BMI chart. Is increasing calories a thing that you need to do? Less likely, right? It's more so probably some of these other things that we need to potentially look at here. Another thing that we can do for these, for some of these people, especially if they have a high training load or again, they've been in a fat loss phase or whatever it may be, is add in some higher calorie days. So sprinkling in higher carbohydrate refeed days may help offset some of these, you know, adaptations over time. But remember, they aren't a substitute for spending a meaningful period of time eating more calories at maintenance, at your true maintenance. Eventually, you still need a longer phase of adequate energy intake, not just a few higher calorie days each week here. And again, this would be someone that's actively dieting, high training load on the leaner side there. A lot of it comes down to calories, making sure somebody eats a little bit more, but it could also be just carbohydrates. It may not necessarily be adding in calories. It could be, hey, we need to make sure you're well fueled for the amount of training that you're doing. Obviously, when we increase carbohydrates, there's a good chance we're also increasing calories. So keep that in mind. But again, not everybody needs to increase their caloric intake, but a lot of these people do. When also reducing unnecessary training volume, I think is super important. And again, we can't neglect prioritizing sleep, circadian rhythm, and stress load management while also looking at micronutrient intake, because these will be things that that really can impact this, despite outside of just the calories there. So I hope this episode was helpful and gave you some insight into okay, maybe just because my weight's stable doesn't necessarily mean that fueling enough, I still may need to increase things there. If you guys have any questions on this episode, reach out to me on Instagram, Jeff HN underscore. And if you found this podcast to be helpful in any way, if you could leave a rating and review, and that will help more people find it. So that's it for now. I want to talk to you guys soon. Thank you for listening. If you want more free content like this, follow me on Instagram at Jeff H91 underscore or visit jh.net. See you next time.
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
Iron Culture presented by MASS
Eric Helms & Eric TrexlerStarting Strength Radio
Mark Rippetoe
The Stronger By Science Podcast
StrongerByScience.com
3D Muscle Journey
3D Muscle JourneyBeast over Burden powered by Barbell Logic
Barbell LogicBarbell Medicine Podcast
Barbell Medicine
Dave Tate's Table Talk
elitefts.comThe Diet Doc Podcasts
Dr. Joe Klemczewski
Docs Who Lift
Docs Who LiftThe Revive Stronger Podcast
Revive Stronger
RP Strength Podcast
Nick Shaw
Strong and Sleek
Robert Santana