Wits & Weights | Evidence-Based Fitness & Nutrition for Lifters Over 40
Wits & Weights is a strength and nutrition podcast where in every episode I put a popular piece of fitness advice under the microscope, find the hidden reason it doesn't work, and give you the deceptively simple fix that does.
For skeptics of the fitness industry who are tired of following the rules and still not seeing results. If you've been lifting weights, tracking macros, and doing "all the right things" but your body composition hasn't changed, you're probably overcomplicating it. This is the fitness podcast that shows you how to build muscle, lose fat, and achieve a real body recomp by focusing only on what the evidence actually supports.
Evidence-based fat loss coach Philip Pape brings an engineer's approach to strength training, nutrition, and metabolism. Instead of another generic program or meal plan, you get specific, science-based strategies for optimizing body composition, whether you're focused on building muscle, losing fat, or both. The focus is on strength training over 40, hormone health, perimenopause and menopause, and longevity.
You've seen the conflicting advice. One expert says cut carbs, the next says eat more. One says train six days a week, another says three is plenty. Building the body you want doesn't have to be this confusing or time-consuming. By using your wits (systems + identity-based behavior change) and lifting weights, you can build muscle definition, improve your physique, and maintain your results for life without rebound weight gain.
You'll learn smart, efficient strategies for movement, metabolism, muscle, and mindset, such as:
- Why fat loss matters more than weight loss for both your health and your physique
- Why all the macros, including protein, fats, and yes even carbs, are critical to body composition
- How just 3 hours a week of proper hypertrophy training can deliver better results than most people get in twice that time
- Why building muscle is the single most powerful thing you can do for metabolic health, longevity, and aging well
- Why perimenopause and menopause don't have to derail your progress when your training and nutrition are dialed in
- How shifting the way you think about fitness can unlock more physical (and personal) growth than any program alone
If you're ready to learn what actually works with evidence-based training and nutrition, hit "follow" and let's engineer your best physique ever!
Popular Guests Include: Mike Matthews (author of Bigger Leaner Stronger), Greg Nuckols (Stronger by Science), Alan Aragon (nutrition researcher), Eric Helms (3D Muscle Journey), Dr. Spencer Nadolsky (Docs Who Lift), Bill Campbell (exercise science researcher), Jordan Feigenbaum (Barbell Medicine), Holly Baxter (evidence-based physique coach), Laurin Conlin (physique coach), Lauren Colenso-Semple (nutrition researcher), Karen Martel (hormone optimization expert), Steph Gaudreau (women's strength and nutrition), Bryan Boorstein (hypertrophy coach)
Popular Topics Include: hormone health, metabolism optimization, hypertrophy training, longevity and healthy aging, nutrition tracking, best protein powder selection, strength training over 40, women's fitness, perimenopause, menopause, muscle building, body recomp, macros and nutrition tracking
Wits & Weights | Evidence-Based Fitness & Nutrition for Lifters Over 40
Women's Hormone Testing, Treatment, & Q&A
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Register for the Live Q&A with Karen Martel taking place TODAY, October 14 at 12p ET / 9a PT, only in Physique University (replay available if you're listening to this later). Use code FREEPLAN to get a free custom nutrition plan when you join at physique.witsandweights.com
Get hormone creams and oils without a prescription at witsandweights.com/karenmartel (use code WITSANDWEIGHTS for 10% off)
--
Enjoy this short replay (from Ep 135) with hormone specialist Karen Martel on how women should test testosterone, why SHBG changes your free hormone levels, and how fasting, carbs, and thyroid meds shape results. We share timing tips, key labs, the 5‑alpha pathway, and smarter steps before adding therapy.
And what about intermittent fasting, keto, and carb cycling?
Join us for today's Q&A with Karen Martel at 12pm ET / 9am PT
💪 Join Eat More Lift Heavy - A 6-month coaching program for lifters over 40 who are done collecting information and ready to have real human coaches watch their data and know what to focus on each week.
📱 Get Fitness Lab (exclusive 20% off) - The #1 adaptive fitness and nutrition app. Daily coaching, workouts, and biofeedback-based guidance to help you build muscle and lose fat over 40.
👥 Join our Facebook community - For adults over 40 who want to build muscle, lose fat, and stop following bad advice. Weekly Q&A threads, coaching insights, and real chat with other lifters.
👋 Ask a question or find Philip Pape on Instagram
Bonus Replay & Live Q&A Invite
Philip PapeHey Wits and Wits of Family. Today is a quick bonus episode. It's a replay of a conversation with hormone specialist Karen Martell about testosterone for women. This was from early 2024, and I'm replaying this because Karen is joining us for a live QA today, exclusively in Physique University. I wanted you guys to get a taste for the kind of specifics that she gets into regarding the mechanisms of our hormones, as well as how to test, how to interpret, what your doctor might be missing, how to treat it, what options are available. So very short, under 10 minute replay today. If you want to ask Karen questions about hormones, perimenopause, menopause, optimizing your health, join us in physique university, go to wits and weights.com slash physique. Use my code FREEPLAN to get a free nutrition plan. And when you sign up today, you can hop on the call at 12 Eastern. If you miss it, there will be a replay. But if you could join live, you'll be able to ask her your questions. I also want to let you know I fixed a broken link in our most recent episode with Karen. There was a link in the show notes to her hormone creams and oils that you can get without a prescription. So that link is fixed in the show notes. It's witsandweights.com slash Karen Martell. And then use code Wits and Waits for 10% off. I'll throw all that stuff in the show notes, but enjoy the replay on testosterone with Karen. Let's go back to testing, right? Because testing's always a point of confusion, especially in the traditional healthcare system where it's like, if you could even get them to give you a test, it's blood work. And usually that's not adequate, but it might be for testosterone. So let's let's break it down. Exactly. That's one thing that makes it easy, right? So how should a woman get access, get tested, and then use the results properly.
When to Test and What to Order
Fasting, Carbs, Protein, and SHBG
Karen MartelSo once again, some really shitty man-to-woman things here, which is testosterone's the only one that they'll ever test free and total. Women would they won't do estradiol free and total or progesterone free in total. It's only testosterone, which is a little bit frustrating. But you can't, that's a very accurate way to test your testosterone. And testosterone, we have a little bit of a peak right before we ovulate, I think to give us that drive to go out and have sex and procreate. But pretty much we don't fluctuate like we do with our other hormones throughout the month with testosterone. It stays pretty even keo. We have that little flux on day 12 right before we ovulate on a 28-day cycle. But you know, besides that, you can kind of just test whenever in the cycle. You probably don't want to test on that peak day. Day 21 is what I would recommend because that's where we test the esterdiol and progesterone in fertile women. So might as well do your testosterone then too. And so it is very accurate, but you definitely want to do both free and total in case your SHBG is too high. And then test your DHEA sulfate in blood, test your sex hormone binding globulin. So we see if it's elevated. Because one of the things that's happening right now is that a lot of women are fasting and fasting like hardcore fasting, you know, one meal a day, two meals a day, and they've been doing this for a long time, or they've been eating a really low carb diet, or and when they're fasting and not eating that much, they're also really low in protein. So low protein diets, low carb diets, too much fasting will all raise SHBG because it makes sense. If we were back in hunter-gatherer days and there wasn't a lot of food around, so we're fasting, right? Then the body is being told, don't get pregnant. There's not a lot of food around. And so SHBG naturally would go up because there's a food shortage. So it wants to bind up your testosterone, bind up your estradiol, and so that you can't get pregnant. And so too much of that starts to signal to the system, don't get pregnant, which is that's really the only reason why we're here. So your body's gonna compensate for this, whether you like it or not, where whether you want kids or not, or care about being fertile, this is what happens. So we have to be really careful with that. So testing that's a good idea.
Philip PapeSo a couple of things, because I actually just put together a new episode about carbs coming out. And one of the interesting things about a higher carb diet was the increase in testosterone to cortisol ratio that they've seen, not in addition to the increase in IGF one that you talked about. So the fasting and the low carb and the low protein, are you saying that that in general for most women that's not recommended because of this? Or what are you saying there?
Finding the Balance: Insulin and Cortisol
Thyroid Meds Raising SHBG
Karen MartelIt's it's a fine line, is what I'm saying, because we also become more insulin resistance resistant because of the drop in hormones as we age, which means intermittent fasting can be a really, really important tool to start implementing because we will we need help being insulin sensitive. It's that women are taking it too far, they get results, and then they're like, oh my God. And then they stop getting results and they think, I better do it harder longer. Right? Like, I better, oh, if I'm eating two meals a day, I better eat one meal a day. Oh, I should be doing a 36-hour fast or a five-day fast. And you you hear this from a lot of like of the big practitioners that are out there on social media saying, like, you, you know, do five-day fast once a month, you know, do one 36-hour fast every single week. And I'm like, no, most women can't handle that, especially in menopause. It stresses the system out too much. So you have to find that balance. You have to know where your cortisol levels are, you have to know where your insulin's at. So testing, of course, is super important. We don't, we don't want to guess what's happening in the body. So some women that are insulin resistant, their cortisol's okay, or let's say it's high, then I would probably say, you know what, you need to be intermittent fasting more, but you still want to make sure you're getting in the protein because if not, then that SHBG will go up and it'll bind up those hormones. The other thing that will raise it is thyroid hormones. So if somebody's on thyroid medication, which a lot of women are, they don't realize that that's actually binding up their hormones and sending them into menopause early, which is something that happened to myself and nobody told me. And I was like, what? What's going on? My total levels of estradiol and testosterone are great, but yet I'm missing a period, I'm getting hot flashes, low libido. And then I finally heard Peter Atia on who's huge, he was on Huberman Lab podcast, and he was talking about thyroid medication raising SHBG. And I'm like, what the frick? Why isn't anybody talking about this? Like, how many women are on thyroid hormones? So many.
Beyond Bloodwork: Dutch and Metabolites
Philip PapeA lot of yeah, it's this is why women are so frustrated, right? And because it's I could just imagine like a piano of keys, and every single key is like a different hormone. And as soon as you press one, the other one goes up or down, and they're all so interrelated, right? Yeah. Um, and even the thing about energy availability, which shameless plug, that's what we talk about on your podcast when my episode comes out, energy availability, is that you you need the energy there to support your hormones, but you don't want so much energy that you're gaining a ton of weight, right? And that's where it's like this balance for women to find out.
The 5-Alpha Pathway and Side Effects
Karen MartelLike we can't be, we got to get away from this one size fits all because even though we know that we're still doing it. The majority of women are still going, what's the next best diet out there and trying it? And oh, everybody's doing keto. Well, I'm gonna do keto. And it's like, but is that a good fit for you? Like, where's your thyroid at? Where's your adrenal system at? Where are your hormones? Like, you gotta look at this full picture and then decide, okay, I'm you know, inflamed, I've got PCOS, I'm insulin resistant. Then yeah, keto could be great and it could reverse all of those things, but then you want to, you know, start carb cycling, and you know, there's there's a lot of nuances to it, and everybody has to find what's gonna work for them.
Philip PapeSo going back to the blood work, uh, free and total testosterone, DHA sulfite, SPG, what else?
Modulating DHT and Next Steps
Karen MartelS HPG, yep. And then of course you want to test your acidion progesterone as well, because there is some some evidence that shows that women should actually be like if you're gonna replace your hormones in perimenopause and menopause, there is some research that shows it's actually better to replace estrogen and progesterone first for three months, then put in the testosterone. So I always want to see that full picture. The other way that I I want people to test is through urine metabolite testing. Now, oddly enough, testosterone is actually the least accurate on urine metabolite testing. So you think, okay, well, then why are you saying that we should do this, Karen? Well, in the a Dutch test, which is dried urine hormone testing, we have testosterone on there. We've got the DHEA sulfate on there. But if you have a genetic SNP where you're missing these enzymes called the UGT enzymes, you won't pee out that testosterone. So it looks like you have none when you actually have plenty. So I always want women to do blood work on the same day or the next day so that we can compare the two just in case it's more common in Asian backgrounds. So if you're you've got, you know, if you're Asian yourself or you've got Asian in in your family history, then you may not have that enzyme. I don't have it, so I always look like I have test low testosterone. But the other piece of the puzzle that we want to see on a urine metabolite test that blood work won't show is something called five alpha reductase enzyme. And so there's a fan gauge on the Dutch test, and there's five beta and there's five alpha. If you are leaning towards a five alpha pathway, so the on the fan gauge, if you're way over to the five alpha, it means you convert your testosterone at a higher rate to what's called dihydrotestosterone, which is the most androgenic out of all the androgens. And so that's where we'll see women, if they go on testosterone replacements, then they if that goes up, the DHT goes up, they start having the hair loss, the greasy skin, the acne. And so that's not that's not pleasant. Women can get whispers, have, you know, can start growing the clitinous, as I call it. So your your P your clitoris can actually start to get longer. And you Yeah. Which is not fine. And I've heard of women this happening to them, their voice cracking, and just from being on testosterone replacement.
Philip PapeAnd that's if you lean more toward the alpha side, you said? Correct.
Karen MartelYeah.
Philip PapeAnd does that mean you shouldn't be taking therapy if that's the case, or do you just have to modulate it and be more careful with the dosage?
Karen MartelExactly. And you have to possibly take something that's going to stop that conversion. So it blocks the five-alpha reductus pathway. There's herbals that do it. There's also medication, uh, finasteride and doasteride that will block that conversion. So a lot of women will take the medication so that they can get the benefits of testosterone without having the masculine features. But there's lots of that, like saw palm meadows, really good for it, pumpkin seed. There's a bunch of different things, ink, that can help.
Philip PapeThat's it for today's replay. If you want the full conversation with Karen, including natural supplementation strategies, treatment options, you can go back and listen to the full episode 135. And remember, join us for today's live QA with Karen in Physique University. Go to witsandweights.comslash physique. Use my code FREPLAN again, witsandweights.comslash physique. And I will see you tomorrow for the next full episode.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
Iron Culture presented by MASS
Eric Helms & Eric TrexlerStarting Strength Radio
Mark Rippetoe
The Stronger By Science Podcast
StrongerByScience.com
3D Muscle Journey
3D Muscle JourneyBeast over Burden powered by Barbell Logic
Barbell LogicBarbell Medicine Podcast
Barbell Medicine
Dave Tate's Table Talk
elitefts.comThe Diet Doc Podcasts
Dr. Joe Klemczewski
Docs Who Lift
Docs Who LiftThe Revive Stronger Podcast
Revive Stronger
RP Strength Podcast
Nick Shaw
Weights and Plates Podcast
Robert Santana